Has Joe Buck’s voice deviated from metronomic monotone twice in one play since the infamous Randy Moss moonshine incident? I don’t know — I mute him whenever possible — and it doesn’t really matter.
Nor is it that Buck and Troy Aikman were fooled by the entire Chicago special teams unit. (The camera people were obviously also fooled, as was Chicago’s whole purpose.)
And it’s not just that Buck made football sound unexciting. It’s also not just that during and after the play, Buck — by rote — summed it all up as if Devin Hester’s decoy action and a referee’s penalty flag-toss were the most significant actions underway.
It’s that he didn’t actually describe what was happening on the field.
He lowered the bar for himself and his profession during Sunday’s Bears-Packers game. This is the nadir. (I really, really hope this is the nadir, as I have no doubt that Buck is capable of lowering the bar even further if he and Tim McCarver keep getting paid to ignore baseball games this October.)
As Johnny Knox sprints down the sideline, Buck plods: “Penalty flag comes down.”
By the time he finishes pointing out the penalty marker, Knox has crossed midfield. Buck, still plodding: “As the catch is *made* on the far side of the field by Knox.”
By the time he gets around to telling us that the returner is Knox, Knox is passing the 20 and is on the verge confronting the Green Bay punter, who has shed an attempted block and is about to attempt a tackle. Buck, ploddingly: “A total deke by Devin Hester.” (Who is about to appear on-screen, jogging.) “A flag is down.”
After Buck plods through explaining that the penalty has nullified what was “an interesting play, with Hester moving as if he was going to catch it, when the punt was in the direction of the far sideline, but they’re calling a *hold* to erase the play” — after all that — Aikman’s bedazzlement sounds convincing and lucid: “That thing was set up beautifully. Ohhhh-ho-ho man.”
After hearing Aikman’s exposition and the referee’s inevitably metronomic monotone explanation that there was, in fact, holding, and the play was, in fact, nullified, Buck offers an explanation/analysis of the play that flatly contradicts what anyone not blind just saw: “Watch Devin Hester, he’s calling for a fair catch, everyone’s eyes go to Hester. Meanwhile, the punt is on the other side of the field, and the only person over there is Johnny Knox.”
Meanwhile, the screen actually shows us an unnamed blocker blocking an unnamed punter, both of whom are directly in front of Johnny Knox.
More plodding: “But there’s a hold to erase it,” Buck reminds as Knox sheds the still-unnamed would-be tackler.*
The director behind the screen then, perhaps reluctantly, shows us a tighter angle of an incoherent mass of humanity that Buck has insisted on paying close attention: “Talk about not needing to hold anybody…There’s nobody on that side of the field.”
Buck then contextualizes the play he has repeatedly told us is null: “It would have been one of the plays of the season so far.”
I know I’m going to be disappointed, but I’m hoping the vocally-dull announcers of the future will figure out how to (at least!) describe and analyze more like this:
“The Bears set up a return. Hester signals fair catch. A flag’s down. Knox has it on the far sideline, one man to beat, *breaks* a tackle, touchdown. They’re already calling it back, but that’s a brilliant play on special teams by Chicago. How ’bout that?”
“That thing was set up beautifully. Ohhhh-ho-ho man.”
“The Bears set it up like it was going to Hester, and Tim Masthy was the only Packer who knew where it went. He got over there, but he’s not beating that block *or* catching Knox from behind.”
“You know what, Joe? It didn’t work today, but that’s gonna be a great way for Chicago to counter if teams are going to keep kicking it away from Devin Hester every time. It might not work out like that ever again, but teams will have to guard against it, space out their lanes and defend the whole width of the field. That’ll make Hester even harder to stop.”
* Never mind the part where this broadcast crew mis-attributed the holding penalty to a player who was not even on the field; and never mind the penalty withering away under video replay.